The very nature of tribology makes it lean towards operational thinking in contrast to strategic thinking – it is one major reason tribology is absent in executive suites around the world. Operational thinking applies to the ‘here-and-now’ where the rubber meets the road, or where grease is applied to an aircraft elevator jackscrew. By way of contrast, strategic thinking is intuitive and looks to the future with forecasts.
by Dave Scott
There are a few SAIT members who have maintained continuous membership of the SAIT since its inception in 1985. Garnett Cross is one of them, a loyal and long standing member of the SAIT. We have asked for their views on tribology and its importance, and here are Garnett’s thoughts on the SAIT and the value of membership. Here is his story:
I have been conducting hydraulic training courses since 1974, namely the Maintenance Course and the Advanced Hydraulic Course (Design Course).
I was in the Design Office in the Research Department of AECI, designing specialised machinery to automate the handling of explosives for the mining industry. Naturally one was not able to design using conventional methods, i.e. using electrically driven prime movers, hence the use of hydraulics or pneumatics. Way back in 1974 very few people were conversant with hydraulics, so it turned out to be quite a learning curve. As time passed I was offered a position at Sperry Vickers Hydraulics and Pneumatics Division in Johannesburg. I eventually ventured out on my own in 1974. I have also attended hydraulic courses overseas from time to time.
When the SAIT was established I saw the absolute necessity to incorporate the standards of Tribology in the design and maintenance of hydraulic systems.
By requiring companies using hydraulics, to maintain correct standards in their oil handling, they have saved a considerable amount in down time and equipment loss. One mining company was replacing a 460 litre per minute piston pump and a radial hydraulic motor approximately three times per year. The solution was to install ten micron bi-directional filters in the ‘A’ and ‘B’ lines of the closed loop hydrostatic system lines. After seven years the pump and motor were still working, performing without a problem.
When AC solenoid operated directional control valves are used the solenoids fail as a result of contaminated oil. This statement may sound a little strange. When an AC solenoid is energised there is an in-rush current as the electrical power is applied to move the solenoid, once the armature is in position, closing the magnetic field, the power drops to the holding current. As the spool clearances of directional valves average from twelve to twenty micron, it takes a few minute dust particles to cause the valve spool to stick, resulting in the solenoid coil burning-out. Since the spool is unable to move, the in-rush current remains at a high amperage resulting in the loss of the solenoid. The problem is solved by installing off-line filtration systems on the reservoir, plus in-line filters.
One company wanted to replace their thirty solenoid operated directional control valves with another make as they were replacing the solenoids daily. The standing order for solenoids was 125 per month. Once the oil was filtered the company had no more problems. That was the worst incident that was encountered. Solenoid failures are generally two to three per month, once correct filtration is applied solenoid failures almost cease.
Vane and gear pumps are also susceptible to contaminants in the oil. Pumps have been installed and after three or four days the pumps have to be replaced. Score marks from the contaminants are clearly visible on the pumps inner surfaces. Unfortunately it is very difficult to convince the company personnel the oil is not maintained correctly with proper filtration. It is only when the oil is tested by an outside service organisation, are the personnel convinced.
A survey was undertaken by Mobil Oil in Australia some years ago. The results published indicating that seventy percent of failures in industrial plant was the result of contaminated oil. The figure for failures in construction equipment was ninety percent as a results of contaminates in the oil.
The SAIT has been a source of learning for me in that I have learned from their technical meetings their seminars and conferences both local and international. There are many aspecits of the hydraulic industry which rely heavily on tribology……
From Patrick Swan, SAIT Vice-President, and on behalf of the SAIT Executive Committee, 2019/20:
Doug was mentor to many people during his life because he cared so much for people and their aspirations. He was enduringly honest, and disliked dishonesty in others: that was a quick way of losing his support and friendship.
Doug had one of the greatest enquiring minds that I have ever connected with.He read deeply and had an impressive library.On one hand science, in all forms, but particularly chemistry and physics, and on the other hand history, both of our universe, and of the cultures of our world.He always amazed me with his knowledge of the universe, from the big, astronomical picture, to the smallest atomic structure.
Lubrication, and particularly lubricant development were an early passion for Doug, which he followed all his life, leaving us with his heritage of Herschell Lubricants.Herschell Lubricants are probably as well-known globally as they are in South Africa, which is a massive tribute to his knowledge and research skills.Anyone meeting in his office was always overwhelmed by the number of new product experiments that were on every available space, and even over the windows.
Planning, management and negotiating were Doug’s major strengths, but his family always took precedence.The last time we spoke, only days before his death, he was thrilled to have his family able to visit him in hospital, having come out of ICU, and so looking forward to spending time with his grandson.
It was natural that Doug was a foundation member of the SAIT, and remained a member in good standing ever since it was formed.Along the way he was awarded the Louw Alberts Award, which is presented for an outstanding contribution to tribology over the years in Southern Africa, and was elected as President of the SAIT in 2018.His passion for tribology and the SAIT was a welcome boost to the institute.When elected he was in hospital, in traction after a fall, and sadly he is the only President to die in office, after his almost 20 year battle with cancer.
Right up to the end his mind was clear, he was still reading his science publications, and planning how to improve the SAIT.
From the SAIT Secretariat:
It is with great sadness that the SAIT announces the passing of Mr Doug Herschell, b. 19 July 1942, d. 22 July 2020, aged 78, after his bravely-fought battle with cancer.
In 1985, he became one of the founding members of the South African Institute of Tribology (SAIT), and has remained a loyal member in good standing since then. In 2018, he became President of the Institute, to which he continued to contribute his valuable knowledge, experience and business acumen – and his personal joy in life.
In 2018, Doug received the SAIT Louw Alberts Award in recognition of ‘his significant contribution to tribology and the SAIT, through driving the fundamentals of tribology, and understanding the application, operating condition, base fluid and chemistry required to solve tribological issues’.
Doug’s career in the lubricant industry spanned more that 55 years; his experience in ‘formulating and technicalities earned him an enviable title as “the go-to man” for bespoke industrial lubricant and aerosol solutions’. A year after joining the SAIT, in 1986, he joined Peter, Anne and Colin Gillespie at Swift Industrial, leading this company in growing from 1 product, Herschell Electogliss, to over 400 product lines in 7 countries.
During his years as SAIT President, Doug frequently ‘popped in’ to the SAIT offices at Science Park, bringing along spicey cookies or biscuits and marvellous conversation; at these times, he signed documents and canvassed for advice and participation in many projects through lively phone calls to members, colleagues and friends.
He entertained us with stories of his many journeys on ‘Spaceship Earth’, having lived life to the full throughout his 78 years. We soon learned of his love for his family – his wife, daughters and grandchildren; his passion for scientific research and creation, all enthusiastically enjoyed by Gill, Berice and Isabel; and his delight in all things astronomical. His passion and joy in life – even when fighting the cancer that attacked him, with all the tools that modern medical research could offer him – made him a wonderful companion.
The SAIT will remember their President, Doug Herschell, with fondness and great respect.
Thank you, Doug, for your hours, days, months and years of loyalty and your valuable contributions to the SAIT over the last 35 years.
The SAIT’s condolences go to Doug’s family in this time of loss; and our thanks to them, too, for sharing him with all of us.
Rest in Peace, Doug – and as was said in the Tribute sent to us by Swifts Industrial – we ‘have no doubt that your viewing of the landing on Mars will be far better from where you are now.’
(Some quotations taken from the Tribute to A Great Man received from Grant Gillespie of Swift Industrial, the company that Doug helped run for many years)
From Lucas Lee and Staff:
On behalf of Lucas Lee staff, our condolences to you and Doug’s family . I am sure that he will be greatly missed by his colleagues and friends.
We’re so sorry to hear about Doug’s passing! Our condolences to all of you.
From Hentie Spangenberg at Shell:
A really sad and big loss. Please give our condolences to the family.
From Amanda Jonker at Multotec:
My condolences on the passing of Doug. ☹
From Howard Benade, SAIT Member:
I am sorry to hear about Mr Doug Herschell… This is very sad news and also a great loss to the industry.
From Eben du Plessis, SAIT Executive Committee Member:
I have known Doug for more than
two decades and regarded him as a real gentleman and balanced business man .
What I really appreciated of Doug, was his unselfishness to readily share
knowledge of aerosols and its use in dosing lubricants. His enthusiasm and
business like leading of the SAIT despite his health constraints, set an
example of leadership to make me proud to being associated with the SAIT.
Understanding Friction, Lubrication and Wear
The SAIT is fully aware of the Corona Virus-Covid19 pandemic, and will follow all guide-lines issued by the Government as strictly as possible.
We will continue to keep everyone advised of any changes as they arise.
At present, we are continuing to prepare for our scheduled Lubrication Engineering courses through the year, the next scheduled for 25-29 May in Johannesburg:
We wish everyone continued health and productivity.
Understanding lubrication, friction and wear